History as Science

Melvyn Bragg and guests discuss the importance of geography and ecology in determining world history since civilisation began. The 18th century historian Thomas Carlyle said that world history was the history of what great men have accomplished, but this understanding of history is being increasingly called into question. Professor Jared Diamond’s book Guns, Germs and Steel, which won the 1998 Rhone Poulenc Prize for Science and the Pulitzer Prize for non-fiction, is a re-evaluation of the last 13,000 years of the history of mankind - particularly in the light of geography and ecology. But what are the implications of looking at world history as being determined by geography and ecology? Is environment really the determining factor in history? And if so, what role does cultural heritage play in shaping different histories? With Professor Jared Diamond, ecologist and physiologist at the Los Angeles Medical School, University of California, and author of Guns, Germs and Steel; Richard Evans, Professor of Modern History, Cambridge University.

→ Play on BBC Sounds website

Guests

• Professor Jared Diamond No other episodes
  Ecologist and Physiologist at the Los Angeles Medical School, University of California
• Richard Evans 2 episodes
  Professor of Modern History, Cambridge University

Related episodes

• Early Geology
  
  12 Apr, 2012 550 Earth sciences and geology
• History and Understanding the Past
  
  30 Mar, 2000 900 History
• The City in the 20th Century
  
  12 Nov, 1998 300 Social sciences, sociology and anthropology
• History of History
  
  22 Jan, 2009 900 History
• Heritage
  
  18 Jul, 2002 940 History of Europe
• Catastrophism
  
  30 Jan, 2014 550 Earth sciences and geology
• History’s relevance in the 20th century
  
  3 Dec, 1998 900 History
• Plate Tectonics
  
  24 Jan, 2008 550 Earth sciences and geology
• Hegel’s Philosophy of History
  
  26 May, 2022 900 History
• Archaeology and Imperialism
  
  14 Apr, 2005 930 History of the Ancient World
• The Earth’s Origins
  
  5 Jul, 2001 500 Science
• Strabo’s Geographica
  
  10 Apr, 2014 910 Geography and travel
• Doggerland
  
  27 Jun, 2019 930 History of the Ancient World
• Human Evolution
  
  16 Feb, 2006 560 Fossils and prehistoric life
• The Art of War
  
  12 Jun, 2003 350 Public administration and military science
• The British Empire’s Legacy
  
  31 Dec, 1998 940 History of Europe
• Genetic Determinism
  
  23 Sep, 1999 570 Biology
• The Geological Formation of Britain
  
  22 Oct, 2009 550 Earth sciences and geology
• Fossils
  
  22 Mar, 2001 560 Fossils and prehistoric life
• Feminism
  
  7 Jan, 1999 300 Social sciences, sociology and anthropology

---

Programme ID: p00545f0

Episode page: bbc.co.uk/programmes/p00545f0

Auto-category: 900 (History)