History’s relevance in the 20th century

Melvyn Bragg and guests discuss the study of history this century. One of the debates raging in the practice of history is between the history of facts versus the imagination - a debate raised again by so-called ‘faction’ - fiction based on documentary facts which is so much in our minds today from films and television. But in fact it is a debate which has been going on throughout the century within history. The 19th century historian Thomas Macaulay wrote that History is under the jurisdiction of two hostile powers; and like other districts similarly situated it is ill-defined, ill-cultivated and ill-regulated. Instead of being equally shared between its two rulers, the Reason and the Imagination, it falls alternately under the sole and absolute dominion of each. It is sometimes fiction and sometimes theory.Why is the study of history important? Is history relevant to us today? Are the truths likely to be yielded from history closer to those disclosed in great novels than the abstract general laws sought by social scientists? And what is the role of imagination in the writing of history? With Simon Schama, Old Dominion Professor of Humanities, Columbia University in New York and currently filming a 16-part series for BBC Television on the history of Britain; Lady Antonia Fraser historian, writer and author of biographies of Mary Queen of Scots, Cromwell and Charles II.

→ Play on BBC Sounds website

Guests

• Simon Schama No other episodes
  Old Dominion Professor of Humanities, Columbia University
• Lady Antonia Fraser No other episodes
  

Related episodes

• Heritage
  
  18 Jul, 2002 940 History of Europe
• History and Understanding the Past
  
  30 Mar, 2000 900 History
• History of History
  
  22 Jan, 2009 900 History
• Hegel’s Philosophy of History
  
  26 May, 2022 900 History
• The British Empire’s Legacy
  
  31 Dec, 1998 940 History of Europe
• Biography
  
  22 Jun, 2000 920 Biography and genealogy
• Imagination
  
  28 Nov, 2002 150 Psychology
• Education
  
  4 Nov, 1999 370 Education
• Science in the 20th century
  
  5 Nov, 1998 500 Science
• Truth, Lies and Fiction
  
  15 Jul, 1999 800 Literature, rhetoric and criticism
• Empiricism
  
  10 Jun, 2004 190 Modern Western Philosophy
• The Renaissance
  
  8 Jun, 2000 940 History of Europe
• Memory and Culture
  
  27 May, 1999 150 Psychology
• Victorian Realism
  
  14 Nov, 2002 820 English and Old English literatures
• Icelandic Sagas
  
  9 May, 2013 830 German and related literatures
• The Novel
  
  11 Nov, 1999 800 Literature, rhetoric and criticism
• Modern Culture
  
  21 Jan, 1999 800 Literature, rhetoric and criticism
• War in the 20th Century
  
  15 Oct, 1998 320 Political science
• The Epic
  
  6 Feb, 2003 800 Literature, rhetoric and criticism
• History as Science
  
  11 Mar, 1999 900 History

---

Programme ID: p005458g

Episode page: bbc.co.uk/programmes/p005458g

Auto-category: 900 (History and geography)